Governing Effectively via a Framework for School Governance
Capacity of a board to perform its governance responsibilities. The first responsibility of a board is to develop its capacity to govern.
(49 Questions to Ask Your Board) The most fundamental discipline of a board of directors is to direct the organization for high performance. Directing is a proactive discipline, focused on the future. But an alarming problem exists with many boards: they refuse to direct! – Jim Brown1 The above observation is a clear consequence of the fact that, while it is hard enough for individuals to prepare for a leadership role, it is even more difficult for a board of Read More …
(49 Questions to Ask Your Board) The servant-leader is servant first… It begins with the natural feeling that one wants to serve, to serve first. Then conscious choice brings one to aspire to lead. That person is sharply different from one who is leader first, perhaps because of the need to assuage an unusual power drive or to acquire material possessions. – Robert Greenleaf1 According to Greenleaf, those aspiring to leadership must choose first to serve, then to lead. This Read More …
(49 Questions to Ask Your Board) The development of a governance mindset in our view is the most important characteristic of effective trustees…Having a governance mindset is understanding the role and responsibilities of the governing board and how individual trustee leadership can enhance the positive, value-added impact of the governance process. – Davis Campbell and Michael Fullan1 It is not enough to acquire knowledge (what to know) or skills (what to do) for governance. Boards must as a first priority Read More …
(49 Questions to Ask Your Board) Board Readiness to govern is a board responsibility that sets the stage for carrying out its more observable responsibilities in three areas: Strategic Voice [giving voice to the community’s values and vision – both an outward (advocacy) voice and an inward (policy) voice]; Operational Guidance [providing policy guidance for the superintendent’s management role, the board’s governance role, and individual board members’ boardsmanship role]; and Accountability [assuring on behalf of the community that the district, Read More …
The August issue of The American School Board Journal is now online. Its Features section includes an article (Oath of Office) in which I describe an opportunity that presents itself whenever a new board member takes the oath of office. The rest of the board can more rapidly onboard that new member if they renew and recommit to their own oath at the same time, following up the oath ceremony with a whole-board discussion on the meaning of that oath. Read More …
This month’s edition (February 2023) of the American School Board Journal included a feature article that I wrote, describing leadership, including school board leadership, as a 3-legged stool. Here’s how they introduce the topic: School boards must balance responsibility, authority, and accountability to successfully govern, writes board trainer and long-time school board leader Rick Maloney. Here’s a link to that article: The Three-Legged Stool
5 Topics that are useful for board member training, and 2 topics that are of no value (or even cause harm) to board member development.
I posted an entry (the first of three installments) on 8 lessons learned in the 19 years since our board first learned about the Policy Governance (R) model of John Carver. This model is one way to approach the responsibilities of governance described on this site – A Framework to Governance. The first part deals with three lessons learned: Be wary of assumptions Change our mindset It’s all or nothing You can read this entry at policy.governance101.com Another successful model Read More …
Board success depends on many elements, including the organization’s leadership and culture, the board’s actions, knowledge, and character, and the situation, but the purpose of board leadership can be simply defined as assuring, on behalf of the community, that the organization succeeds. One way to portray leadership is a three-legged stool – each leg must be present for the three to stand together – consisting of responsibility, authority, and accountability. Leaders at every level, including the board in its leadership role, must accept full responsibility for their level in the organization. They must know those whom they serve. They must assign responsibility for doing the work. They must delegate sufficient authority over the work to get the job done. And they must assure accountability for the work. Before all else, they must take responsibility and be accountable for the board’s own performance.
School boards should review 6 areas to help focus their efforts: the state, the community, the students, the district, the superintendent, and (most important) the board itself.